Tire repair service near Shelter Island, NY

Friendly, quick service...Eric offered me a same-day inspection despite being fully booked. Also quickly diagnosed a loud whine I was hearing on a used truck I bought (loose carburetor gasket). This place came highly recommended and I see why.

The worst! They kept my car for thirteen weeks to do a five-six hour job and charged $400 more then the dealer quoted. "Doc" Reid barked like a junkyard dog when I stopped by to ask when he would be done. Stay away.

i had the unfortunate experience of getting an estimated price of $500 for brakes and rotors. I said ok . They were to call me with exact price but I called them . They wanted 1600.00 for brakes oil change wipers !! Padded the quote like no tomorrow!! I called my local mechanic and he had his tow truck get my vehicle They wouldn't release my car unless I signed paperwork via email that they didn't receive without me making a 38 dollar payment as the said they Inspected the Brakes! Then he wouldn't release my car because he wanted me to write my debit card number on an unencrypted email. He finally extorted this 38 dollars from me and kept the tow guy waiting for a half hour.

I've been doing business at Palumbo's for years. I would trust them with any vehicle I own! They are kind, and honest. They even took photographs of my worn brake pads and emailed them to me so that I could understand what needed to be done!